How to Handle Talented Players with Attitude Problems: A Guide for Coaches

Summary: Manage high-talent, tough-attitude players by pairing empathy with equal standards: diagnose root causes individually, set and enforce clear team rules, reward effort, leverage peer culture and parent partnerships, and model composure—turning volatility into growth and competitive edge without sacrificing the locker room.

---

Managing talented players who exhibit attitude problems can be a delicate balancing act. On one hand, coaches must correct poor attitudes and bad behavior or they’ll lose control of their team. On the other hand, talented players are needed on the court to boost morale and win games.

How are coaches supposed to handle players with poor attitudes – especially when they're crucial to a team’s game plan?

Here are some tips for addressing these challenges effectively while fostering trust and respect within your team.

Understand the Individual

Every player is unique, and a one-size-fits-all approach to coaching rarely works. Spend time getting to know what motivates your players and what might be causing the negative behaviors. For instance, some players act out due to stress or lack of confidence, while others may simply crave attention or feel underchallenged. Building rapport and asking open-ended questions like, “What do you feel you need to succeed?” can provide valuable insights into their mindset.

Set Clear, Consistent Expectations

Maintaining consistent behavior expectations for all players, regardless of skill level, is important. Talented players may sometimes feel they can bend the rules because of their abilities, but fairness fosters respect. Clearly outline team rules and reinforce them consistently to create an environment where every player knows what’s expected. As Gabe Infante, a successful high school coach, emphasizes, “Consistency is the foundation of your core values as a coach” (Hudl Blog).

Leverage Positive Reinforcement

Recognize and reward good behavior to encourage compliance and motivation. Praise their effort during drills or games to build their confidence and emphasize that improvement and teamwork matter more than raw talent. Avoid over-reliance on punishment; instead, have private conversations about misbehavior to address issues without embarrassing the player in front of the team (Stack) .

Use Team Culture to Drive Accountability

A strong team culture can help players self-regulate their behavior. Foster an environment where team members hold each other accountable. Peer influence can often be more powerful than directives from a coach. Encourage discussions about shared goals and values and involve players in setting standards for the team.

Engage with Parents as Partners

Parents can be invaluable allies when dealing with challenging athletes. They often understand their child’s personality better than anyone and can provide insights or help reinforce your messages at home. When addressing concerns with parents, be tactful and emphasize their child’s potential while discussing ways to improve their behavior (Stack).

Keep Your Cool and Lead by Example

Frustration is natural when dealing with difficult players, but staying calm and composed is essential. Your reactions set the tone for how the team handles challenges. Show empathy for what the player might be experiencing off the court while making it clear that personal issues should not overshadow team goals. As one coach put it, encourage players to “clear the mechanism” and focus entirely on the game during practice or matches (Hudl Blog).

Questions for Reflection and Discussion

Handling challenging personalities is part of the journey in youth basketball coaching. The ultimate goal is not just to win games but to help players grow as individuals and teammates. With patience, clear communication, and consistent effort, you can turn attitude problems into teachable moments that benefit the player and the team.

Sources: Stack, Hudl