<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src="https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=739617211739985&amp;ev=PageView&amp;noscript=1">

From Practice to Performance: Helping Athletes Excel Under Pressure

Coaching Fundamentals Dec 12, 2025 2:44:32 PM Coach Wolfe 6 min read

help athletes perform under pressure header

Summary: Mastering the pick and roll demands attention to fundamentals like timing, screening, communication, and flexibility, enabling teams to exploit defensive weaknesses and elevating overall offensive effectiveness. Coaches who teach both the details and the variations of this play empower players to make high-IQ decisions and consistently create scoring opportunities.


As a basketball coach, few things are more frustrating than seeing a talented team perform exceptionally in practice but falter during games. When teams are capable of playing well, but fall short under pressure, this disconnect may stem more from psychological challenges with your players rather than skill deficits.

Performance anxiety in sports is a state of intense nervousness, fear and worry that occurs before, during or after athletic competition.

For anyone who is affected, it shows up in their body as a racing heart or shaky arms, in their thoughts as overthinking or self-doubt, or in a lack of focus when they zone out or forget plays.

How can you help?

When I began coaching youth basketball, I expected the role would entail skills training, strategy and even an occasional motivating speech, but I didn't expect how much psychology was involved in the day to day. Luckily there are lots of great evidence-based strategies to help coaches mentally prepare their players for game day and bridge the gap between practice and performance under pressure.

Build Athletic Self-Efficacy

Research has shown that self-efficacy—the belief in one’s ability to succeed—significantly predicts athletic performance. A study found that self-efficacy accounts for 30% of changes in athletic outcomes, making it one of the most influential psychological factors in sports performance. Athletes with high self-efficacy are more likely to stay calm under pressure, adapt to challenges, and perform at their peak during games.

Actionable Tips:

  • Celebrate Successes: Remind players of past victories, whether in games or scrimmages, to reinforce their confidence.

  • Game-Simulated Practices: Introduce drills that mimic high-pressure game scenarios to help players develop confidence in their ability to handle stress.

Reframe the Role of Pressure

Athletes often perceive game situations as a high-stakes test of their ability, which can lead to performance anxiety. Psychologist Martin Seligman’s work in positive psychology highlights the importance of optimism and reframing challenges as opportunities. By shifting the narrative from “must-win” to “chance to excel,” you can help players approach games with a more positive mindset.

Discussion Point:

How do your players talk about game day? Are they focused on fear of failure or the excitement of competing? Encouraging positive self-talk can transform their mental approach.

Incorporate Mental Skills Training

Mental toughness is not just innate—it can be developed. Skills like visualization, mindfulness, and focus training can significantly improve performance under stress. Athletes who visualize successful plays or practice mindfulness during training report higher levels of calm and focus during competition.

Actionable Tips:

  • Teach your players to visualize specific plays or successful outcomes before games.

  • Introduce mindfulness exercises to help them stay grounded and present.

Foster Team Resilience

The concept of “flow,” introduced by Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi, describes a state of peak performance achieved when individuals are fully immersed in an activity. Teams that experience flow often have strong interpersonal connections and clear communication. Building team cohesion can help your players trust one another and perform as a unit.

Actionable Tips:

  • Use team-building exercises that emphasize trust and collaboration.

  • Encourage open communication during practices and games to build a cohesive environment.

Reduce Overemphasis on Perfection

While striving for excellence is important, perfectionism can hinder performance by increasing anxiety. Research suggests that perfectionism contributes to only 21% of performance variability, and its benefits often come with psychological costs. Help players focus on progress and effort rather than flawless execution.

Actionable Tips:

  • Ask your players, “How do you define success in a game? Is it about execution or effort?” Shift the focus from perfect outcomes to growth and learning.

The Final Word

Helping players overcome mental blocks takes time, but with targeted psychological strategies, you can empower them to bring their practice performance to the game floor. By fostering confidence, reframing pressure, and cultivating mental skills, your team will be better equipped to perform at its best.

What strategies have worked for you in the past? Do you notice any common mental barriers among your players? Let’s continue the conversation and share insights to build stronger, more resilient teams.

For further reading:

Coach Wolfe

Hi! I'm Mike Wolfe. I’ve coached high school basketball for 15 years, and if there’s one thing I know for sure, it’s that growth never stops for players or coaches. I created Hoop Leaders to share what I’ve learned, admit what I’m still figuring out, and collaborate with coaches who believe the job is bigger than wins and losses. Here, we trade ideas, sharpen fundamentals, build confidence, and strive to keep our athletes mentally, physically and spiritually healthy—so they leave our programs better players and even better people. I hope you'll join us!


Let's Coach Better, Together.

Read to join the community and start earning rewards?